The Night the Books Burned — The Inventory of Fear

Mahdawiyyah, Part 26 · The Architecture of Guidance, Part 10 · The House Beside the Grave, Part 2 Somebody sat down and wrote a list of everything that made us who we are — and then went and got each thing on it, one at a time, and put it in a fire in the street where everybody could see. In the year 448 after the Hijra, a new power took Baghdad without a fight. Within a year the house of Shaykh al-Tusi in the Karkh quarter had been sacked, his notebooks burned, and the chair he had taught from for forty years carried out into the road and set alight in front of a crowd. What is astonishing is not the violence. It is the inventory. A Sunni chronicler of Baghdad — a Hanbali, writing a century later, with no reason at all to be kind to us — records what they came for: a line in the call to prayer, a sentence carved over the doors of people's houses, three pieces of white cloth on poles that ordinary pilgrims carried on the road to Kufa, and a chair. Not one dirham of value in any of it. They were not robbing a house. They were subtracting a community — its voice, its confession, its direction, its transmission. And they were exactly right about the list. The question underneath it What actually protects a people when the state turns on them? The answer this session gives, and then spends an hour proving, is: not a building. What the evening covers How a city changes hands. A family off the steppe, one morning in the desert that rearranged the East, and the plain fact that the new power was sent for. The orders were issued by the caliph's own government, in Arabic, on Abbasid paper. A correction we owe our own dead. The version of this night that most of our community carries in its head is not the version the sources support — and this session says so, in detail, before anyone else has to. Verify the report before you decide who hated you. The purge before ours. The first religious persecution this new state carried out fell on Sunni scholars, in another city, two years before it reached us. That fact belongs in this room. A word that is wrong in the book. One word in the chronicle's key sentence is corrupt — not mistranslated, wrong in the printed edition and in the manuscripts behind it, and wrong for a thousand years. We show how it broke, and why the fix is certain. The machine does not care whose hands are on it. The same administrative apparatus that was used against one community in 449 was used against the other in 450. Not Shi'a against Sunni. Truth against the abuse of truth. A note on the two halves This session and the next are one argument split across two evenings. Tonight is what was taken. Next week is what could not be — and it turns out to be a piece of paper.

In this session

Sermon: The House Beside the Grave, Part 2 of 9 - The Night the Books Burned — The Inventory of Fear

Read

Maqtal: The Man with the Chisel

Nohe/Nasheed: TBC

Ziyarah: Ziyārat Āl-e Yāsīn (The Visitation/Salutation of the Family of Yasin)

Play Read