---
title: "The Mujtahid"
event: "The Lantern of the Path"
session_number: 84
published_at: "2026-11-25"
canonical_url: "https://www.truthpromoters.com/events/the-mujtahid"
event_url: "https://www.truthpromoters.com/events/the-lantern-of-the-path"
type: "event-session"
scripture_reference: "Nahjul Balagha, Saying 478, Section 1"
---

# The Mujtahid

*Session 84 of [The Lantern of the Path](https://www.truthpromoters.com/events/the-lantern-of-the-path) — 25 November 2026*

**_Mahdawiyyah, Part 40 · The Architecture of Guidance, Part 23 · Those Who Carry It, Part 5_**

## The Mujtahid

**Everyone wants the answer. Nobody wants the years. What does it cost a man to be able to say that something is God's ruling — and why did the ones who had earned that right most often ask not to be the one to say it?**

Last week we followed the scholar out of the lesson and among the people. Tonight we go back inside, to the long years before a single answer is given. It opens with a letter Imam Ali, peace and blessings be upon him, wrote to the man he had just sent to govern Egypt, describing the kind of man to choose as a judge: one who is not content with the nearest understanding of a matter when there is a further one, and the most cautious of all when things are doubtful. It opens with a question God puts in the Qur'an: whether He has given leave for what people call His law, or whether it is invented and laid at His door. And it opens on a birthday in 1994, when a man whose name had just been placed on the lists of those fit to be followed asked that his name not be read out.

Then what the work is, and what it costs to learn it. Imam al-Rida, peace and blessings be upon him, gave the picture of a tree: the Imams cast the roots, and the scholars trace the branches, drawing out what was already there. What a scholar must master before he may give one answer. A young man from a small town in the south-west of Iran who went to Karbala at eighteen and spent years on the road from one teacher to the next; and a teacher in Najaf who came to his mosque an hour early, heard an unknown shaykh teaching two or three students in a corner, and took his whole class to sit at that shaykh's lesson.

And then the fear. A dying great jurist who named his successor and told him to lessen his precautions. A man handed the leadership of the Shi'a world who said he was not fit to be followed, named a fellow student he thought more precise, and, when there was no one else, went to the shrine of Imam Ali to ask to be kept from error. An Imam who left his own house, so that nobody could think he wanted power. The keys to the room where the poor's money was kept, put into a mother's hand; a house searched for weapons, and found without even a carpet. And how a ruling travels from the one who made it to you: what happens to it when it is passed on carelessly, when a question is shaped to bring back the answer someone wanted, or when a name is put on top of an answer that named nothing.

### The question underneath it

**If, while the Imam of our Age, may our souls be his ransom and may God hasten his return, is hidden, God's law reaches us through the people who labour to draw it out — what does it cost them to say that something is God's ruling, and what do we owe a ruling once it reaches us?**

### What the evening covers

- **The roots and the branches.** What a mujtahid is, what he must master, and why nobody becomes a scholar of the law by tomorrow.

- **I am not fit.** The men who refused the office, named someone better, and took it up only when the burden would otherwise have been left on the ground.

- ***A trust with me.*** The rights of the poor kept even from family; and the chain of trust that runs from the one who gives a ruling, through every teacher, parent and family group, to you.

- **When a ruling sounds strange.** Whose fault that is, and how a ruling can be bent without anyone telling a lie.

- **Lessons for our time.** Six of them, for the one people come to and for the people who come to him: from the funeral where someone asks how an estate is divided, to the ruling forwarded with a name on top of it.

**It ends with a man who lived at the head of the Shi'a world in a house with no carpets, and who lies today in the courtyard of the shrine he went to when the burden was laid on him.** And the maqtal is for Imam Muhammad al-Jawad, peace and blessings be upon him: a boy of nine on a cushioned seat, with a chief judge before him; and a small boy in Medina who wept over his lesson at the very hour his father died, far away in Baghdad.

## Scripture

> وَقَالَ (عليه ‏السلام): مَا أَخَذَ اللهُ عَلَى أَهْلِ الْجَهْلِ أَنْ يَتَعَلَّمُوا حَتَّى أَخَذَ عَلَى أَهْلِ الْعِلْمِ أَنْ يُعَلِّمُوا.
>
> Amīr al-mu’minīn, peace be upon him, said: Allāh has not made it obligatory on the ignorant to learn till He has made it obligatory on the learned to teach.

— *Nahjul Balagha, Saying 478, Section 1*

## Programme

- Sermon: The Mujtahid
- Maqtal: He Moves Us to Himself
- Nohe/Nasheed: TBC
- [Ziyarah: Ziyārat Āl-e Yāsīn (The Visitation/Salutation of the Family of Yāsīn)](https://youtu.be/E2epjzOIGvo) · [written](https://www.shiasounds.com/p/ziyarat-al-e-yasin-the-visitationsalutation)

## Other sessions in this event

- [Session 83 — The Scholar Among the People](https://www.truthpromoters.com/events/the-scholar-among-the-people) — 18 November 2026
- [Session 82 — The Teacher](https://www.truthpromoters.com/events/the-teacher) — 11 November 2026
- [Session 81 — The Student](https://www.truthpromoters.com/events/the-student) — 4 November 2026
- [Session 80 — What Is A Scholar?](https://www.truthpromoters.com/events/what-is-a-scholar) — 28 October 2026
- [Session 79 — Why a Marja'?](https://www.truthpromoters.com/events/why-a-marja) — 21 October 2026
- [Session 78 — What Is a Hawza?](https://www.truthpromoters.com/events/what-is-a-hawza) — 14 October 2026
- [Session 77 — The Empire That Called Itself Islam](https://www.truthpromoters.com/events/the-empire-that-called-itself-islam) — 7 October 2026
- [Session 76 — Can It Become That?](https://www.truthpromoters.com/events/can-it-become-that) — 30 September 2026
- [Session 75 — Who Else Asked This?](https://www.truthpromoters.com/events/who-else-asked-this) — 23 September 2026
- [Session 74 — Is This Idol Worship?](https://www.truthpromoters.com/events/is-this-idol-worship) — 16 September 2026
- [Session 73 — Why People Go](https://www.truthpromoters.com/events/why-people-go) — 9 September 2026
- [Session 72 — Why Najaf?](https://www.truthpromoters.com/events/why-najaf) — 2 September 2026

---

_Read this session on the web: https://www.truthpromoters.com/events/the-mujtahid_
